Nova Scotia lobster pound owner wins appeal of ‘grossly disproportionate’ 2-year suspension

November 21, 2023 Canada

The Nova Scotia Supreme Court has overturned a two-year ban from the lobster business imposed on a pound owner caught with lobster harvested under an Indigenous licence that does not permit selling the catch. Justice Pierre Muise said the penalty imposed on Tyler Nickerson, owner of Fisher Direct in Shag Harbour, N.S., was overkill. “The grossly disproportionate severity of the sanction imposed in the case at hand, and the lack of any discernible reasonable justification for it, make it such that the minister’s decision was arbitrary,” Muise said in a decision released Tuesday. >>click to read<< 15:08

an August 2018 raid of Fisher Direct, disproportionate' 2-year suspension, Justice Pierre Muise, lobster pound owner Tyler Nickerson, Nova Scotia, Nova Scotia Fisheries Minister Steve Craig, Nova Scotia Supreme Court, owner of Fisher Direct, social or ceremonial (FSC), tagged for Indigenous food, wins appeal

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ocean Resource Privatization

Articles Posted by Date
April 2024

M T W T F S S

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

8 9 10 11 12 13 14

15 16 17 18 19 20 21

22 23 24 25 26 27 28

29 30

« Mar

April 2024
M	T	W	T	F	S	S
1	2	3	4	5	6	7
8	9	10	11	12	13	14
15	16	17	18	19	20	21
22	23	24	25	26	27	28
29	30

The New England groundfish debacle (Part III): who or what is at fault? Nils E. Stolpe/FishNet

It took me a while to decide how to most accurately describe the situation that has been visited upon the New England fishing communities that are and since colonial times have been dependent on the groundfish fisheries.

NILS STOLPE: The New England groundfish debacle (Part IV): Is cutting back harvest really the answer?

While it’s a fact that’s hardly ever acknowledged, the assumption in fisheries management is that if the population of a stock of fish isn’t at some arbitrary level, it’s because of too much fishing. Hence the term “overfished.” Hence the mandated knee jerk reaction of the fisheries managers to not enough fish; cut back on fishing. What of other factors? They don’t count. It’s all about fishing, because fishing is all that the managers can control; it’s their Maslow’s Hammer. When it comes to the oceans it seems as if it’s about all that the industry connected mega-foundations that support the anti-fishing ENGOs with hundreds of millions of dollars a year in “donations” are interested in controlling. Read the article here

Recent Posts
- Cape Cod: Summing up the seals
  
  When David Pierce seated himself at the table at the Nantucket Seal Symposium last month, one image came to mind: private pilot Aaron Knight’s video from Read More »
- DA drops charges against Beverly lobsterman
  
  A Beverly lobsterman is off the hook on charges that he caught more than 100 illegal lobsters. The Essex District Attorney’s Office has dropped a nearly Read More »
- Prosecutors get extension of deadline to indict New Bedford fishing magnate Carlos Rafael
  
  Prosecutors have received an extension of the deadline to indict local fishing magnate Carlos Rafael, a U.S. District Court spokesperson confirmed Friday. The length of the Read More »
- Fund compensating Newfoundland seafood industry could resolve one of the final obstacles to CETA deal
  
  With the United States poised to adopt a more protectionist trade policy under President-Elect Donald Trump, some good news for supporters of Canada’s major trade deal Read More »
- It’s here – the future of commercial fishing
  
  New trawling technology – billed as “the future of sustainable fishing” – has been unveiled to the New Zealand seafood industry at its annual conference in Read More »
- Lobster Boat Races come to Rockland
  
  Lobstermen in Rockland weren’t hauling any traps today, but that doesn’t mean their boats weren’t in action. Summer in Maine is actually multiple seasons rolled into Read More »
- South Atlantic Fishery Management Council Seeks Public Input on Use of Vessel Monitoring Systems
  
  The South Atlantic Fishery Management Council is requesting public input on management alternatives that may require the use of vessel monitoring systems (VMS) on vessels with Read More »
- New Bedford again tops nation for dollar value of fishing catch
  
  The city’s port has again topped the country for dollar value of its fishing catch, NMFS reported this week, citing 2015 landings worth $322 million. That Read More »
- Heavy damage along Maine coastline as ocean inundates with powerful surf
  
  The coastline suffered major damage with high tide occurring around 9:30 a.m., Jan. 10, 2024. The ocean was washing over all infrastructure, ripping and tearing property Read More »
- Nova Scotia fishing industry granted intervenor status in Mi’kmaw treaty rights case
  
  The ruling Friday afternoon by Supreme Court Justice John Keith gives the Unified Fisheries Conservation Alliance standing in a proceeding against the Canadian government by the Read More »
- Commercial harvester says seals, not climate change, is the reason for decline of cod in New England
  
  An Associated Press story recently drew a comparison between the decline of cod in the United States with what happened to the northern cod stocks in Read More »
- Three years on from the Brexit poll NI fishermen still determined to leave EU
  
  For nearly 50 years Northern Ireland’s fishing industry has felt trapped by European Union restrictions on catch quotas and the rights of foreign trawlers to operate in Read More »
- In Remembrance – Recalling the Heather Lynne II
  
  Sometime before dawn on Sept. 5, 1996, the Heather Lynne II — a 45-foot fishing boat out of Newburyport — capsized off the coast of Cape Read More »
- Lobster traps washed up on Great Bores Head, Hampton, NH, Finder would like to get them back to the owners
  
  We just got this email, and If you’re missing some gear, you could check with Bev Hollingworth. AT OUR HOUSE ON GREAT BOARS HEAD “BARNACLE” WE Read More »
- Editorial: Feds must hold Commerce to law on fishery aid
  
  Disappointing, embarrassing, offensive — all of those words can be applied to the fact that White House senior adviser Valerie Jarrett largely ignored Gov. Deval Patrick’s Read More »
- It’s been called the “Saudi Arabia of wind power” and it includes some of the most fertile fishing grounds in the world.
  
  Every April, North Atlantic right whales, some of the largest and most endangered species in the world, come here to feed. It’s a super highway for Read More »
- The Coastal Fishing Industry Grant Program – After Hurricane Sandy, fishing businesses get more help
  
  The Coastal Fishing Industry Grant Program, announced May 20 by Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s office, was created with $20 million in federal funding. According to the governor’s Read More »
- Earth Day: Not a Single Environmental Prediction of the Last 50 Years Has Come True
  
  We should be thankful that the gloom-and-doom predictions made throughout the past several decades haven’t come true. Fear-mongering about explosive population growth, food crises and the Read More »
- Let’s go to Canada! 60 thousand offer to those who know how to wash fish
  
  Canada based company, located in Quebec, offers jobs for Mexicans with fish washing experience. The best part is that there is a striking salary of 60 Read More »
- Modernizing a Fishing Vessel for Optimal Performance
  
  Elliott Bay Design Group (EBDG) is supporting O’Hara Corporation as they modernize their 204′ factory trawler, Alaska Spirit. The vessel has been successfully fishing Alaska’s Bering Read More »
- ITS HUGE! Grey Sole limits nearly doubled as scientists use ’empirical approach’ to set new specifications
  
  Meeting in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, the New England Fishery Management Council approved an acceptable biological catch of 878 metric tons of witch flounder, also known as Read More »
- F/V Mucktown Girl: TSB weighing what steps they will take next, including opening an investigation
  
  The F/V Mucktown Girl halibut boat went down off the coast of Canso, N.S., on Sunday. Four of its five crew members were rescued by the Read More »
- New Dakota Creek fishing ship will be first in U.S. since 1989
  
  Commissioning a new ship costs a bundle. Ask Helena Park, CEO and founder of Fisherman’s Finest in Kirkland. She has hired Dakota Creek Industries in Anacortes Read More »
- Lobsterman’s wife
  
  My husband gets up around 4 a.m. to go lobstering on days that the weather allows. By 5 o’clock, he’s down at the boat and headed Read More »
- ‘We’re not going to stop fighting’: Families of F/V Chief William Saulis crew to keep pushing for safety in fishing industry
  
  Michelle Nickerson-Forbes had worried that the longer it took for the Transportation Safety Board to come out with its report about the December 2020 fatal sinking Read More »