All (fisheries) models are wrong

Tag Archives: All (fisheries) models are wrong

All (fisheries) models are wrong, but some are useful (to indigenous people)

August 1, 2015 Canada, Marine Science, National

Models do a great job of distilling the essence of how an ecosystem might respond to external forces—such as fisheries—but only under the specific conditions that the modeller assumes to be true in the ‘world’ of the model. Sometimes these assumptions are well-grounded in reality. Sometimes they are blatant but necessary simplifications. Phil is a lively character, a fishery ecologist who runs the Ecosystem Science section of the Northwest Fisheries Science Center The cool thing about Phil, who I have met personally several times, is that he will tell you right off the bat that “models are bogus”. Read the rest here 12:44

Comment

Ocean Resource Privatization

Articles Posted by Date
November 2024

M T W T F S S

1 2 3

4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11 12 13 14 15 16 17

18 19 20 21 22 23 24

25 26 27 28 29 30

« Oct

November 2024
M	T	W	T	F	S	S
	1	2	3
4	5	6	7	8	9	10
11	12	13	14	15	16	17
18	19	20	21	22	23	24
25	26	27	28	29	30

The New England groundfish debacle (Part III): who or what is at fault? Nils E. Stolpe/FishNet

It took me a while to decide how to most accurately describe the situation that has been visited upon the New England fishing communities that are and since colonial times have been dependent on the groundfish fisheries.

NILS STOLPE: The New England groundfish debacle (Part IV): Is cutting back harvest really the answer?

While it’s a fact that’s hardly ever acknowledged, the assumption in fisheries management is that if the population of a stock of fish isn’t at some arbitrary level, it’s because of too much fishing. Hence the term “overfished.” Hence the mandated knee jerk reaction of the fisheries managers to not enough fish; cut back on fishing. What of other factors? They don’t count. It’s all about fishing, because fishing is all that the managers can control; it’s their Maslow’s Hammer. When it comes to the oceans it seems as if it’s about all that the industry connected mega-foundations that support the anti-fishing ENGOs with hundreds of millions of dollars a year in “donations” are interested in controlling. Read the article here

Recent Posts
- Sam Parisi – Unless we have the science compared to an independent survey we are in peril at NOAA hands
  
  I was reading an article in South Coast Today regarding the new director of NOAA Jon Hare who said quote, he is willing to talk to Read More »
- How Bering Sea crab fishing was made safer
  
  The dangers of the Bering Sea crab fishery have been made famous by the reality TV show “Deadliest Catch.” But in the last 15 years, that industry Read More »
- North Atlantic Right Whale: Extinction Is Looming. Everyone’s Fighting.
  
  This May, new rules created for the lobster industry by the National Marine Fisheries Service will become official policy for boats operating in right whale territory. Read More »
- Why You Should Eat Wild Caught Fish From the Great Lakes
  
  We have been following the plight of commercial fishing on the Great Lakes for several years. As a result, we have been contacted by folks around Read More »
- Maine shrimp industry in such dire straits season might be called off this year
  
  PORTLAND, Maine — Maine’s Gulf of Maine boats traditionally take to the waters of the Gulf of Maine the first week of December. But not this Read More »
- Everything you’ve heard about ‘ropeless’ fishing gear is false.
  
  Is so-called “ropeless” fishing gear the magic bullet for the perceived problem of marine mammal interactions in California’s crab fisheries? (what about the New England lobster Read More »
- Trawlers and Milford Haven’s history
  
  As promised, in TRM Trawler Corner this week is Shielburn M15, a steel sided trawler built in Aberdeen in 1911, which landed at Milford from May Read More »
- ‘These Waters Are Hot’: U.S. Auction Opens Up Offshore Wind Farm Rush
  
  When the U.S. last auctioned big plots of ocean to companies that wanted to build offshore wind farms a few years ago, it raked in a Read More »
- The port of Galilee/Point Judith has lost an iconic member, Jack Westcott
  
  Jack B. Westcott, 91, of Charlestown, passed away Monday. He was the husband of Elinor Pinkham and the late Lillian (Holmes) Westcott. He is survived by Read More »
- XtraTuf Says Their Boots Are Better
  
  Two years ago, parent-company Honeywell transferred production of iconic Alaskan footwear brand XtraTufs from Rock Island, Illinois, to a factory in China, and the product that Read More »
- Editorial: Cape Pond Ice’s plight shows impact of fishery losses – Gloucester Daily Times
  
  The Cape Pond Ice case shows once and for all that this economic disaster is not “just” about fishing. It’s about the entire city’s economy – Read More »
- Boys will be boys. Just not here! Motels cast drunken, bed-wetting fishing crews adrift
  
  Drunken, bed-wetting fishing crews are unwelcome at South Canterbury motels. South Canterbury Moteliers Association president Maree Winter said people coming off fishing boats were behaving badly, Read More »
- Fisherman who died going overboard from F/V Lady Brittany on Jan. 21 has been identified
  
  Paul Sayward, 36, of Wareham, was identified as the fisherman who went into the water on Jan. 21 some 50 miles off the coast of Nantucket Read More »
- Atlantic cod pushing out Arctic relatives?
  
  When I visited the AWI Biological Institute on the German North Sea island of Helgoland last year for a story on how climate change is affecting marine Read More »
- Hawaii’s longline fleet about to hit its 3,554-ton bigeye tuna limit, enviro scorned rule will keep them fishing
  
  Hawaii’s longline fleet is about to hit its 3,554-ton limit for bigeye tuna in the Western and Central Pacific, prompting a closure date for the fishery of July Read More »
- Maine Lobster Boat Racing: NASCAR meets tractor pulls
  
  To Patrick Hanley, it was the extra salt that did it. A 19-year-old lobsterman from Bass Harbor, Hanley ran about 6½ knots faster during the lobster Read More »
- Groundswell – Revisiting MSA Reauthorization 2006 – Who Owns the Flying Duck? by Terry Haines
  
  Who owns the air? Who owns the ocean? Who owns a duck flying overhead, on his way to his summer house in the Arctic marshes? Does everyone? Read More »
- Maritime Explorer: Captain Cameron McLellan
  
  As a skilled sailor and navigator, Cameron McLellan hails from a family of multi–generations of seafarers. On the paternal side, the McLellans have hundreds of years of fishing in their Read More »
- Fisheries Minister Gail Shea has canceled two funding announcements that had been scheduled for Friday.
  
  No reason was given for the cancelations; however, blowing snow and about five cm of snowfall is predicted to cause travel problems across Atlantic Canada today. Read More »
- Fighting for the fishing grounds in the face of offshore wind farms
  
  For almost a half century, Angela Sanfilippo has spearheaded campaigns to protect the physical and economic health of commercial fishermen, their families and the communities in Read More »
- Coronavirus is making it difficult for Whatcom’s commercial fishing fleet this season
  
  A new report from the Regional Economic Partnership at the Port of Bellingham indicates the local fishing fleet is dealing with a host of hurdles this summer, particularly Read More »
- Michael Peele: A family fishing tradition lives on
  
  Michael Peele is the quintessential Outer Banks fisherman — resolute, generous, hard-working and deeply connected to his heritage. Peele lives in Hatteras village on land owned Read More »
- Missing Digby County man found dead in Sissiboo River
  
  Graham Cromwell, a lobster fisher from Weymouth Falls, N.S., who went missing in the Sissiboo River on Wednesday, has been found dead about a kilometre away from Read More »
- Edited: With Sadness and Regret. Fisherman David Oakes of South Thomaston Maine
  
  It has been noted that Fisherman David Oakes of South Thomaston Maine has passed. It appears he had acquired the F/V Terra Nova, and was excited Read More »
- Stock assessments show Maritime lobster population strong, fishery sustainable
  
  Adam Cook is a DFO biologist who tracks lobster populations along the Scotian Shelf and Bay of Fundy, waters that support nearly 3,000 commercial licence holders Read More »